@Ronzuki 4 days in, it's still starting. I will get a starter relay before the problem happens again. I'm convinced the problem lies within the starter relay or solenoid. If it is the solenoid I'm pretty sure I would be better off buying the whole starter, for I haven't seen the solenoid sold separa...

I checked all the connections on the starter and battery and put the starter back on. For now the car is starting fine. I'll keep you guys posted if the problem returns. Thanks for the advice.

@Triggerhappy, The battery and alternator both tested good. Advance Auto tested the alternator, it tested good as well.

I have 2010 All wheel drive, CVT, S, 2.4 engine. Sometimes when I press the start button, I here a click under the hood but won't cranks or won't crank in the same day., other times it starts just fine. Sometimes it takes a few days for it to start again. Sometimes it starts or not in the same day. ...